(TAX UPDATE) The Most Common Mistakes Found During an LHDN PCB Audit

(TAX UPDATE) The Most Common Mistakes Found During an LHDN PCB Audit

Introduction

A PCB audit letter is short. Five pages of instruction with two Lampiran, a fourteen day deadline. Read in order, they tell you exactly what HASiL is testing and where it expects to find the gap.

Here is what required documents/information and why the last two decide the outcome.

Lampiran 1/1: the master checklist

Lampiran 1/1 is the list of everything you must produce, for the two years of remuneration under review. It runs to fourteen items, and they group into four purposes.

The payroll evidence. Your salary register or payroll records including bonuses, for every director and every employee. This is required not only for staff where PCB was deducted, but also for anyone whose gross monthly remuneration reached RM3,100 or more even where no PCB was deducted. Gross here means basic salary, overtime, allowances, incentives and other payments, but not genuine reimbursements. Alongside it, payment vouchers for anything paid outside the payroll, such as director's fees and bonuses. Employers running manual payroll must complete Lampiran B for every director and employee.

The statutory identity of the directors. Recent SSM extracts, which the letter specifies as Sections 17, 78, 58, 236(2) and 15 where applicable, to identify by full name and identity card number the directors responsible for the company. Read that against the payroll request and the intent is plain. HASiL wants to know who the directors are before it looks at how they were paid.

The annual returns and statements. Your audited financial statements, the Form EA for all directors and employees, the CP8D employee schedule, and where relevant your TP1 and TP3 forms and your e-CP39 submissions. Plus a current staff list, and an employee listing showing names, identity or passport numbers, start dates, cessation dates and notice dates.

The movement forms. CP22 for new employees, CP21 for employees leaving Malaysia, and CP22A for employees who cease work. These prove you told HASiL when people arrived and left, which is how it checks that no one dropped off the payroll untaxed.

Item fourteen is where Lampiran B and Lampiran C are called in by name.

Lampiran 2/1: the digital file specification

If you run a computerised payroll system, Lampiran 2/1 asks for three files, not paper: the Employee Master File, the Payroll Register File, and the payroll Chart of Account.

The format is prescribed to the character. Delimited text using the bar, the pipe symbol. A header of three lines on the first page only, carrying company name, year of remuneration and record count. Column names on a single row. Each file named by your employer E number joined to the words MASTER, PAYROLL or CHART, with a .txt extension.

This is where preparation quietly fails. If your payroll vendor cannot export in this exact layout, you find out late in a fourteen day window. Ask the vendor now, before any letter arrives.

Lampiran 2/2: the Employee Master File column order

Lampiran 2/2 sets the exact column sequence of the Employee Master File, and it is more revealing than it looks. In order, it wants the employee number, name as per identity document, identity or passport number, religion, date of birth, category (clerk, officer, director), start date and cessation date, marital status, spouse name and identity number, whether the spouse is working, and the count of children broken down by relief band, including disabled children and those over eighteen still studying at diploma level and above.

That is not administrative trivia. It is the profile that drives the PCB category. Marital status, spouse income and the children bands determine whether an employee falls under Category 1, 2 or 3, which sets the deduction. HASiL is reconstructing the inputs to your PCB calculation so it can test whether the output was right. Note too that category is where directors are flagged in the same file as everyone else.

Lampiran B: the month by month confession

Lampiran B is the Penyata Saraan and Potongan Cukai (PCB), the payroll summary. For every director and every employee, it lays out the year one month at a time.

Look at the columns. Gaji pokok, overtime, insentif, komisen, and sitting among them a dedicated column for Yuran Pengarah, the director's fee. Then Jumlah Saraan Kasar (gross), KWSP, Saraan Bersih, Zakat, PCB Telah Dilakukan (PCB actually deducted) and Potongan CP38. The category and number of children carry across from the master file profile.

The power of the form is the layout. Gross on one line, PCB deducted next to it. Any month where money was earned and the PCB column reads zero is visible at a single glance. Two features make it unforgiving. The RM3,100 line means you cannot leave lightly taxed people off the schedule. And the form ends with a signed employer declaration that the figures were copied from the company's original records. You are not estimating. You are certifying.

Lampiran C: the questions aimed at the director

Lampiran C drops the summary and asks direct questions. Read questions four to seven and the target is unmistakable.

Question 4 asks whether the director receives a salary. Question 5 asks whether the director receives a director's fee, and if so, when it was paid, who received it, and whether PCB was deducted, then requires you to attach the director's account ledger. Question 6 asks whether any bonus was paid to directors and employees, and when. Question 7 asks whether the company provides directors and employees with benefits in kind, a car for example, or living accommodation. Questions one to three and eight set the scene: business activity, the payroll system used, the PCB calculation method, and zakat receipts.

Each question maps to a specific exposure.

The director's fee and the ledger they asked for

A director's fee is employment income under Section 13(1)(a) of the Income Tax Act 1967, taxed on the same progressive scale as salary, and the company must deduct PCB when it pays the fee.

The classic SME mistake is timing. The fee is approved at year end and credited to the director's account, but no cash moves and no PCB is deducted. That is exactly why Lampiran C asks for the director's account ledger. It is where a credited but undeducted fee shows up. The timing rules for directors of controlled companies under Section 29 of the Income Tax Act 1967 can treat a fee that is approved but unpaid as receivable in the following year, fixing the year it becomes assessable, while the PCB obligation bites when the fee is paid or credited.

A fee sitting in the accounts with no PCB, and no matching entry on Lampiran B, is the most common finding in an owner managed company audit. Underneath it sits a company law point too: under Section 230 of the Companies Act 2016, directors' fees require shareholder approval in general meeting.

Bonus: the same trap, a different month

A bonus is part of gross remuneration and must be included in the PCB computation for the month it is paid, which usually pushes that month's PCB sharply higher. A director's year end bonus paid without running through PCB creates exactly the gap Lampiran B exposes. A large December gross beside a small December PCB writes the officer's next question for them.

Benefits in kind: the exposure that never touched payroll

Questions seven and nine reach beyond cash entirely. A company car provided to a director is a benefit in kind under Section 13(1)(b). Living accommodation is taxable under Section 13(1)(c).

Here is the subtlety. Benefits in kind and living accommodation are not part of the remuneration on which monthly PCB is compulsorily deducted. That is why they get missed. It does not make them tax free. They remain fully taxable, belong in the director's Form EA, and form part of chargeable income, valued under the LHDN Public Ruling on benefits in kind using either the formula method or the prescribed value method.

Question nine is the mechanism. It asks you to list the assets the company owns or rents, the cost or current value, the date acquired, the name of the director or employee enjoying the benefit, and how many months in the audited year they used it. For a vehicle used in business it wants the log book. From that table HASiL can compute the annual benefit in kind value itself and compare it against what the director declared, which is often nothing, because the car sat in the company's name and no one treated it as income.

Why the director is the target

Read the five attachments together and the design is clear. Lampiran 2/2 profiles every person including the director in one file. Lampiran B lines up gross against PCB so gaps cannot hide. Lampiran C then interrogates the director alone: salary, fee, bonus, car, accommodation, and the ledger they all live in. In a typical Malaysian SME the owner is the director, the employer, and the largest single item of remuneration. The staff payroll behaves. The director's pay is the part that gets structured, deferred, credited and paid in kind.

How to prepare

Do not fill these forms at the deadline. Reconcile first.

Map every item on Lampiran 1/1 to a document you actually hold. Test your payroll export against the Lampiran 2/1 format early, and check the Lampiran 2/2 column order against what your system produces. Rebuild Lampiran B month by month before writing a figure, watching the Yuran Pengarah column and the RM3,100 earners. For Lampiran C, pull the director's account ledger yourself, trace every fee and bonus credited across the two years, confirm PCB was deducted and the fee was approved under Section 230, list the car and any accommodation, find the log book, and confirm the benefit in kind was valued and carried into the director's Form EA. Where it was not, correct it as a voluntary disclosure before the officer raises it.

KTP's View

A PCB audit rarely fails on the staff payroll. It fails on the director, because the director's remuneration is the part that was never treated like everyone else's.

The attachments are built to prove that in sequence. The checklist gathers the evidence, the digital files rebuild your inputs, Lampiran B puts the numbers in a row, and Lampiran C names the fee, the bonus, the car and the ledger. If you can answer all five without flinching, the audit is administrative. If you cannot, they will find it for you.

The work to be ready is not large. It is one honest reconciliation of the director's own pay, done before the letter arrives rather than in the fourteen days after it does.

This article is general information for Malaysian employers and is not tax advice for any specific taxpayer or situation. Statutory references, valuation methods and forms were correct at the time of writing; verify current rules against the Income Tax Act 1967, the Income Tax (Deduction from Remuneration) Rules 1994, the relevant LHDN Public Ruling and HASiL guidance, or speak to a qualified tax agent on your own facts.

Visit Us

  • Wisma KTP, 53 Jalan Molek 1/8, Taman Molek, 81100 Johor Bahru

  • Wisma THK, 41, Jalan Molek 1/8, Taman Molek, 81100 Johor Bahru

KTP (Audit, Tax, Advisory)

An approved audit firm and licensed tax firm operating under the KTP group based in Johor Bahru providing audit, tax planning, advisory and compliance services to clients

THK (Secretarial, Bookkeeping, Payroll, Advisory)

A licensed secretarial firm in Johor Bahru providing fast reliable incorporation, secretarial services, corporate compliance services, outsourcing bookkeeping, and payroll services to clients

KTP Lifestyle

An internal community for our colleagues on work and leisure.

KTP Career

An external job community on vacancies in Johor Bahru for interns, graduates & experienced candidates.

#Thk

#KTP


taxKtp KtpPcb audit lhdn